You’ve probably heard real estate and investment moguls preach that renting your home is the smarter financial move. For example, Grant Cardone famously advocates that you should “rent where you live, own what you rent to others” and only buy assets that produce income. While I respect his business acumen, my research and experience tell a different story for most homebuyers.
The Rent vs. Buy Debate: What The Gurus Miss
Cardone and similar investment gurus make compelling arguments about opportunity costs and leveraging capital. They’re not entirely wrong – in pure investment terms, your primary residence isn’t typically producing direct income. But this perspective misses crucial factors that affect real people making real housing decisions.
What these gurus overlook is the forced savings mechanism of home ownership, the psychological security of controlling your living situation, and the long-term wealth building that occurs even through the worst market cycles.
My South Florida Case Study: Buying at the Worst Possible Time
I wanted to test this theory with real numbers, not just theory. So I analyzed what would have happened if someone bought at the absolute market peak in South Florida in late 2005 – literally the worst timing imaginable.
The results? Even with catastrophically bad timing, buying eventually outperformed renting. It took longer than anyone would have liked – almost 18 years for the investment to truly pay off – but it did happen. The homeowner who stuck it out through the 2006-2011 crash, and almost to the present day, ultimately built more wealth than their renting counterpart.
Why? Because:
• Property values historically recover and appreciate over long time horizons,
• Tax advantages accumulate significantly over decades, and
• Inflation works in the homeowner’s favor by devaluing fixed-rate debt.
It took 14 years – until 2019 – for the median property’s value to exceed what it was at the 2005 market peak. But then values appreciated briskly from 2020 through 2024. By 2023, buying was the better deal, and the margin should grow from there. And that’s under the worst case scenario ever to affect South Florida prices.
Further enhancing the benefit is that mortgage payments eventually end, but rent payments never do.
My analysis assumed you invested into the stock market the down payment you would have made buying a home, and achieved an average rate of return. Now, if you are the second Warren Buffett of investing, well then, renting might be the better call. But even Buffett himself has lived in the same home for more than 50 years, says that the psychic benefits of home ownership are immense, and considers his house to be one of the best investments he ever made.
My Current Strategy: The Value-Added Approach to Home Ownership
Based on this research and my experience in real estate and mortgages, I’ve developed a strategy that amplifies the advantages of home ownership, and reduces the risks:
1. Spend less than your financeable maximum on the home; don’t be “house poor”.
2. Limit your down payment to 10 percent or less if possible.
3. Target undervalued neighborhoods with strong fundamentals.
4. Find homes needing certain strategic improvements – not total disasters, but properties where specific upgrades will significantly boost value.
5. Leverage renovation loan products like Fannie Mae HomeStyle to finance both the purchase and improvements with one loan at a favorable rate.
6. Execute these smart renovations that improve both livability and value, creating instant equity.
7. Hold and enjoy your improving asset while the neighborhood continues to appreciate around you.
This approach combines the stability of home ownership with the value-creation principles that investment gurus rightly emphasize. You’re building wealth through both regular payments and strategic improvements, while simultaneously securing your long term living situation.
Specifically, some examples of great locations in Northeast Broward County would be
- West Wilton Manors (west of Andrews) – preferable to Middle River Terrace and Lake Ridge;
- Imperial Point, Coral Ridge Isles, Knoll Ridge, and Oakland Park Corals – more so than Central Wilton, East Wilton, and Poinsettia Heights; and
- Deerfield Beach Cove – better than Lighthouse Point and East Pompano.
*****
The “rent vs. buy” question isn’t black and white. But for those willing to take a strategic approach to home ownership, buying can be both financially rewarding and personally satisfying – even if Grant Cardone and others would tell you otherwise.
What’s your experience with the rent vs. buy decision? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.